RICS Red Book & IVS methodology · Independent valuers +61 422 026 728 contact@assetvaluations.ae
Asset Valuations — Professional Valuations Dubai Request valuation
Menu+
Services+
Insights+
Knowledge hub+
About
Locations+
Our process FAQ Glossary
By purpose · 04

Valuation in disputes and separation

In a contested matter the figure is only half the argument. The valuation date, the basis, the discounts applied and the evidence behind each of them are where cases are actually won.

Disputed valuations follow a pattern. Both sides accept the asset exists, broadly accept the method, and disagree about three things: the date, the assumptions, and the adjustments. A report that deals with those three head-on is worth several that simply assert a number.

What is really in dispute

  • Date. Separation, cessation of trading, the breach, the exit notice, the hearing — each produces a different figure.
  • Basis. Market value, fair value between shareholders, or a formula written into an agreement years ago.
  • Adjustments. Minority discounts, marketability discounts, owner remuneration, related-party terms and one-off items.

Matrimonial and separation matters

Family matters for non-Muslims are governed by Federal Decree-Law No. (41) of 2022 on Civil Personal Status, with home-country law available by election in defined circumstances; matters involving Muslim parties are governed by the applicable personal status legislation. The framework determines what is divided and on what principles — questions for your lawyer. What we supply is the valuation of what is on the table: the family home, investment property, vehicles, and any interest in a private company.

Discretion matters as much as accuracy here. Reports are prepared for the instructing lawyer, and inspections can be arranged without disclosing purpose to tenants, staff or counterparties.

Shareholder and partnership exits

Start with the constitutional documents. Shareholders' agreements and articles frequently prescribe a valuation mechanism — an expert determination, a named basis, a formula, or a fair-value standard that expressly excludes minority discounts — and that mechanism generally governs regardless of what an unconstrained valuation would produce. Reading it before instructing a valuer avoids paying twice.

Beyond the documents, the recurring issues are normalisation of the accounts, the treatment of shareholder loans and related-party trading, the effect of customer concentration, and whether the departing party's stake is valued as a proportion of the whole or as a minority holding in its own right.

Discounts and premiums

Discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability are legitimate, frequently decisive and often overstated. They should be evidenced and reasoned in the report — by reference to the rights actually attaching to the shareholding, the realistic exit routes and observable data — rather than applied as a conventional percentage. An unexplained discount is the easiest part of any valuation to attack.

Working with the court expert

In onshore proceedings the court will usually refer the technical question to an appointed expert. A party valuation prepared early gives the expert evidence to test, frames the questions the expert must answer, and provides the material from which objections to the expert's report are drafted. Prepared after the expert reports, the same document carries far less weight.

Preparing your file

  1. Agree the valuation date, or the competing dates, with your lawyer before instructing.
  2. Provide the constitutional documents and any agreement containing a valuation clause.
  3. Provide complete financial records, including the ones that do not help you.
  4. Identify the assets that may need separate treatment — property, vehicles, plant, intellectual property.
  5. Allow time for legal translation into Arabic for onshore filings.
? — Questions

Dispute valuation questions

01Can you value at more than one date?+

Yes, and in contested matters it is often sensible. Where the date is itself in dispute, valuing at each competing date shows the court what turns on the question.

02Will a valuation clause in our shareholders' agreement override the market?+

Usually. Where the parties have contracted for a mechanism or a formula, that generally governs. Read the clause before instructing anyone — it may also dictate who may be appointed.

03Is a minority discount always applied?+

No. It depends on the rights attaching to the shareholding, the basis of value adopted, and any contractual standard such as fair value between shareholders that excludes it.

04Do you act as an expert witness?+

We prepare independent reports for use in proceedings and support them through queries and objections. Court-appointed expert work is a separate function performed by experts registered with the relevant judicial authority.

05Can the report be kept confidential?+

Reports are prepared for the instructing lawyer and named users. Inspections can be conducted discreetly, and we do not disclose engagements.

§ — Primary sources

Verify it yourself

Elsewhere in the hub

Valuation evidence in courtHow court-appointed experts work. Business valuationsEquity and enterprise valuation methodology. Probate & inheritanceDate-of-death valuations for estates.
Important notice

This page is general information about the regulatory framework applying to valuation in the United Arab Emirates. It is not legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not a substitute for the text of the legislation or for guidance from the relevant authority. Laws, fee schedules, thresholds and certificate validity periods change; always confirm the current position with the Dubai Land Department, the Abu Dhabi Real Estate Centre, the Federal Tax Authority, the Ministry of Justice or a qualified adviser before acting. Reviewed August 2026.

In a dispute, or about to be?

Send the pleadings or the agreement and tell us the date in issue. We will scope a report your lawyers can file, and support it through to the hearing.

Request a valuation +61 422 026 728